Do You Really Need a Garbage Disposal?

For many homeowners, a garbage disposal feels like a kitchen must-have—until it starts leaking, jamming, or smelling like a science experiment. But do you really need one? The answer depends on your lifestyle, plumbing system, and how you use your kitchen.

Garbage disposals are designed to make cleanup fast and easy. They break down small food scraps that might otherwise clog your drain, keeping your pipes clear and your trash lighter. For families that cook frequently, a disposal can be a real convenience. However, not every kitchen is equipped for one—especially older homes with outdated plumbing or septic systems that aren’t designed to handle excess organic waste.

It’s also important to understand that disposals aren’t invincible. Fibrous foods, grease, coffee grounds, and bones can jam or dull the blades. What starts as convenience can turn into frequent repairs if not used correctly. And while modern disposals are much quieter and more energy-efficient, they still require careful installation to prevent leaks and odor buildup.

If you’re replacing your sink, it’s the perfect time to decide whether to install or remove a garbage disposal. A professional can evaluate your plumbing and recommend whether it makes sense for your setup.

At I Hate My Sink, we help homeowners choose what works best for their kitchens—not just what’s trendy. A disposal can be a great tool, but it’s not essential for everyone. The key is installing what complements your cooking habits and keeps your sink performing at its best.

‍